Source A
GreenTech Solutions is a manufacturer of eco-friendly electronic devices. The company is considering relocating its production facility from the UK to either Germany or Poland. The UK facility is currently facing high operating costs and regulatory pressures. Germany offers a skilled workforce and proximity to key markets, while Poland provides lower labour costs and government incentives for new businesses. GreenTech Solutions aims to reduce costs and improve competitiveness in the European market.
Source B
| Location | Labour Costs | Rent | Utilities | Transportation | Total Costs |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| UK | |||||
| Germany | |||||
| Poland |
a) Define the term 'location decision' [2 marks]
Show model answer
A location decision is the process of choosing the best geographical site for a business to operate in. This decision considers factors such as costs, market access, regulatory environment, and availability of resources. [2 marks]
b) Calculate the difference in total operating costs per unit between the UK and Poland. Show your working. [3 marks]
Show model answer
Difference in total operating costs per unit between the UK and Poland: UK total costs: 30.00 GBP Poland total costs: 22.00 GBP Difference: 30.00 - 22.00 = 8.00 GBP [3 marks]
c) Explain two factors that GreenTech Solutions might consider when deciding to relocate from the UK. Refer to Source A. [4 marks]
Show model answer
Two factors GreenTech Solutions might consider when deciding to relocate from the UK are: 1. Operating costs: The UK facility has high operating costs, which could be reduced by moving to a location with lower costs, such as Poland. [2 marks] 2. Regulatory pressures: The UK has regulatory pressures that might be less stringent in other locations, allowing the company to operate more efficiently. [2 marks]
d) Analyse the advantages and disadvantages of relocating to Germany or Poland for GreenTech Solutions. Use information from Sources A and B. [6 marks]
Show model answer
Advantages and disadvantages of relocating to Germany or Poland: Germany: Advantages: 1. Skilled workforce: Germany offers a highly skilled workforce, which can improve the quality of production. [2 marks] 2. Proximity to key markets: Germany's central location in Europe provides easy access to major markets. [2 marks] Disadvantages: 1. Higher costs: Germany has higher labour costs and rent compared to the UK and Poland. [1 mark] Poland: Advantages: 1. Lower labour costs: Poland offers significantly lower labour costs, which can reduce overall operating costs. [2 marks] 2. Government incentives: Poland provides government incentives for new businesses, which can help offset relocation costs. [1 mark] Disadvantages: 1. Potential language and cultural barriers: Poland may present language and cultural challenges for a UK-based company. [1 mark] [Total: 6 marks]
e) Evaluate the most suitable location for GreenTech Solutions to relocate to, justifying your answer with reference to Sources A and B. [5 marks]
Show model answer
Model answer: The most suitable location for GreenTech Solutions to relocate to is Poland. This decision is based on the following reasons: 1. Lower operating costs: Poland offers the lowest total operating costs per unit (22.00 GBP) compared to the UK (30.00 GBP) and Germany (35.00 GBP). This can significantly reduce the company's expenses and improve profitability. [2 marks] 2. Government incentives: Poland provides government incentives for new businesses, which can help GreenTech Solutions offset the costs of relocation and establish its operations more easily. [1 mark] 3. Market access: While Germany offers proximity to key markets, Poland's lower costs and incentives make it a more attractive option for reducing overall expenses and improving competitiveness. [2 marks] Level-of-response guide: Level 3 (5-6 marks): A clear and well-justified evaluation of the most suitable location, with detailed reference to Sources A and B. The response demonstrates a thorough understanding of the factors influencing location decisions and provides a logical and well-supported conclusion. Level 2 (3-4 marks): A reasonable evaluation of the most suitable location, with some reference to Sources A and B. The response demonstrates a basic understanding of the factors influencing location decisions but may lack detail or depth in the justification. Level 1 (1-2 marks): A limited evaluation of the most suitable location, with minimal reference to Sources A and B. The response demonstrates a limited understanding of the factors influencing location decisions and provides little justification for the conclusion. [Total: 5 marks]